Tag Archives: Review

The Hobbit Reviews have arrived and uh oh!

8 Dec
Director Peter Jackson at the World premiere o...

Director Peter Jackson at the World premiere of the third part of Lord of the Rings in Wellington, New Zealand. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

A Certified Fresh logo.

A Certified Fresh logo. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The Hobbit reviews have finally been posted and so far not so good. On the web site Rotten Tomatoes which which monitors the percentage of positive reviews by critics has The Hobbit at only 70% positive thus far.

The bigger issue is that of all the positive reviews mostly have come from internet critics, such as bloggers. For example this review is positive. I’d say it’s  a little early to hit the panic button, but I’m concerned. So far top critics, which is what Rotten Tomatoes calls critics like Roger Ebert and the New York Times critic A.O Scott, have been mixed in their praise. Only 1 out of 5 reviews counted thus far has been positive. Even that one was not high praise.

So far Roger Ebert hasn’t reviewed The Hobbit;he’ll probably do it next week.

The common theme of the negative reactions has been the movie is too stretched out and too long. This makes me concerned that Peter Jackson’s appendix excuse might just be a way of disguising it as a cash grab. Normally I can live with a movie being just a cash grab–if the movie is Taken 2 or Ice Age, not The Hobbit. Another thing that worries me is that Peter Jackson has become so obsessed with making technology on this film great that he forgot to care about the story.

I’m probably freaking out a little more than I need to right now because I’ve seen the 6 new clips from The Hobbit and they’re great. I probably should not freak out until more critics see the film, and I see it myself.  I’m planning on personally seeing it twice, once in Imax 3D and  the other time in the controversial 48 frames per second. Even having read the movie’s negative reviews of the format, I have to see it at least once in this format because honestly it’s worth at least giving it a try and I don’t get sick on roller coasters.

Even though I should wait, the reviews so far do give me some reason to worry. My fear is that the film is so poorly received that the box office for parts two and three suffer and the legacy of these movies held so high by Lord of the Rings is forever tarnished.

Roger Ebert, american film critic.

Roger Ebert, american film critic. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Advertisements